This article discusses the High Court case of Petronas Carigali Sdn Bhd (“PCSB”) v Pemungut Duti Setem (“Collector”) [2023] MLJU 639, which examines how stamp duty is assessed on an agreement for the supply, delivery and commissioning of material or equipment, i.e., gas compressor bundle assembly and casing (“Agreement”).

Case Background

  • PCSB executed the Agreement dated 13 January 2020 titled “Provision of Supply, Delivery and Commissioning of Gas Compressor Bundle Assembly and Casing for B11 Compressor Change-Out Project for Petronas Carigali Sdn Bhd”.
  • The Collector assessed an ad valorem duty of RM53,849.00 under Item 22(1)(a), First Schedule of the Stamp Act 1949 (“SA 1949”), considering the total contract value as fixed at RM53,848,626.00 under the Agreement. 
  • PCSB objected to this under Section 38A of the SA 1949, contending that the contract was for equipment supply, and the Collector had erred in determining the estimated or provisional service price in the Agreement as the contract value and assessing it under Item 22(1)(a). Instead, the Agreement should qualify for a nominal RM10 duty under Item 4 of the First Schedule. 
  • On 6 May 2020, the Collector rejected PCSB’s objection via a single-sentence response citing Item 22(1)(a), without providing legal or factual reasons. PCSB subsequently appealed to the High Court under Section 39 of the SA 1949.

Key Legal Issues

The issues put forward before the High Court are: 

  1. Whether the Agreement for the supply of equipment with provisional service scope and estimated service costs should be assessed under Item 22(1)(a) or under Item 4, First Schedule of the SA 1949; and
  2. Whether the Collector has a legal duty to provide reasons for rejecting a taxpayer’s objection.

Collector’s Submission on Appeal

  • The Collector contended that the contract price had been determined at RM53,848,626.00 based on the Agreement, and thus, its stand and decision in subjecting the Agreement under Item 22(1)(a) is justified and correct in law and fact.
  • The Collector further argued that there exist elements of service being rendered/supposed to be rendered by the contractor in the Agreement, and hence it is not merely a contract for supply of materials or equipment but also concerns the services which ought to be provided by the contractor under the Agreement. As such, Item 22(1)(a) should apply.

High Court’s Decision

The High Court ruled in favour of PCSB and set aside the Collector’s assessment, holding that:

  1. A contract with service elements is not automatically a service contract: Upon examining the true nature of the instrument, the Court found that the Agreement was solely for the purpose of supply of materials or equipment. The mere inclusion of clauses for provision of services in the Agreement does not necessarily render it as a service contract.
  2. Item 4 applies rather than Item 22(1)(a): For Item 22(1)(a) to apply, the service agreement must be a primary security or agreement for an annuity or ascertainable sum over a definite period. Given that the service scope set out in this Agreement was provisional, the unit rate for optional incidental services was merely indicative, and the duration or frequency of the services was uncertain, the total amount payable for the services or the contract value was therefore uncertain too at execution in order for Item 22(1)(a) to apply, and thus it was subject only to RM10 nominal duty under Item 4.
  3. Collector’s duty to give reasoned decisions: The court reaffirmed that public decision-making bodies are under duty to give reasoned decisions. The absence of a statutory requirement to give reasons does not mean there is no duty to give them unless the statute specifically states so. The Collector’s “one-liner” rejection without legal or factual justification breached principles of natural justice and violated the taxpayer’s legitimate expectations.

Key Takeaways and Commentary

It has been an established principle that the Court looks at substance of the instrument as a whole for stamp duty assessment. This case seems to suggest that where the substance of an agreement is the supply of equipment/goods, the inclusion of incidental installation services to render the equipment functional and operable does not ipso facto turn it into a service contract. 

As such, does this decision then open the door for standard commercial supply contracts with incidental setup such as air-conditioning supply and installation or machinery procurement, to also enjoy nominal RM10 stamp duty under Item 4 instead of ad valorem duty? While it remains to be seen how the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) will apply this ruling in practice, taxpayers now have a pertinent judicial precedent to resist ad valorem assessments where installation is purely ancillary to equipment supply. 

Other than the above, this case also reaffirms that, if the Collector rejects a Section 38A objection with a generic “one-liner” response, taxpayers can challenge the assessment on the grounds of breach of natural justice and failure to give reasons. This decision provides taxpayers with greater transparency and ensures that revenue authorities must always provide substantive justifications for their decisions in an objection situation.

    ***  

    This article was written by Chin Wan Xin (Associate) from Donovan & Ho’s corporate practice. 

    Our corporate practice group advises on corporate acquisitions, restructuring exercises, joint venture arrangements, shareholder agreements, employee share options and franchise businesses, Malaysia start-up founders and can assist with venture capital funds in Seed, Series A & B funding rounds. Feel free to contact us if you have any queries.